#3 An Explanation:
This will not be a regular thing but with this study I think some clarification is called for. It’s going to make for a lot more content than I normally post up but again I think it is necessary. Not crucial so feel free to skip this if you wish. Following commandments and obedience is being talked about in this study and we need to assure we understand what does this obedience look like? Obedience to what? What does this obedience look like in a Christian’s life?

This is exactly the question that must be answered if we're going to avoid turning John's words into either legalism or vagueness.

When John says:
"By this we know that we know Him, if we keep His commandments." (1 John 2:3) the immediate question is, "Which commandments?"

Because if we answer incorrectly, we end up either back under the Mosaic Law or in a Christianity so fuzzy that obedience means whatever we want it to mean.

- First, John is not talking about ceremonial Old Testament laws

John is not saying Christians prove their salvation by:
• Keeping kosher
• Observing Jewish feast days
• Offering sacrifices
• Following Levitical regulations

The New Testament repeatedly teaches that believers are not under the Mosaic covenant as a covenant system.

- So what obedience is John talking about?

John actually answers this throughout his letter.
For John, obedience is fundamentally obedience to Christ.
Notice how often he returns to the same themes:
• Believing the truth about Jesus
• Loving fellow believers
• Rejecting sinful patterns
• Walking in the light
• Keeping Christ's word
• Remaining faithful to apostolic teaching

In other words, obedience is not primarily about checking boxes.
It is about a life increasingly shaped by allegiance to Christ.

- What does that look like practically?

It looks like a Christian who:

Repents when he sins.
Not because he is terrified of losing salvation every Tuesday afternoon, but because he loves Christ and hates the sin that disrupts fellowship with Him.
________________________________________
Tells the truth.
Because Jesus is truth.
A believer may fail, exaggerate, shade the facts, or speak carelessly, but there is an increasing commitment to honesty.
________________________________________
Loves other believers.
This becomes one of John's biggest tests.
A person can possess impressive theology, quote Greek verbs, and own seventeen study Bibles.
But if he habitually hates, despises, or refuses to love fellow Christians, John gets very uncomfortable very quickly.
________________________________________
Fights sin rather than making peace with it.
Notice I didn't say "never sins."
John has already said believers do sin.
The question is whether we are at war with sin or comfortably sharing a sofa with it.
________________________________________
Seeks to obey Christ even when inconvenient.
Forgiveness.
Generosity.
Humility.
Purity.
Faithfulness.
These things rarely arrive naturally. They usually require surrender.

- What does obedience not look like?

This is equally important.
John is not describing:
• Sinless perfection
• Constant spiritual victory
• Flawless performance
• Never struggling
• Never failing

If that were his standard, then verse 1 would make no sense:
"If anyone sins, we have an Advocate with the Father."
John expects Christians to fail.
What he does not expect is for them to become comfortable with failure.
The evidence versus basis distinction
This is the crucial point.
Imagine an apple tree.
Apples do not make it an apple tree.
Apples reveal it is an apple tree.
Similarly:
Obedience does not create salvation.
Obedience reveals salvation.
Or to put it another way:
A Christian does not obey Christ in order to become a child of God.
A Christian obeys Christ because he is a child of God.

- John would probably ask a modern Christian something like this:

Not:
"Have you achieved perfection?"
Not:
"Have you had enough spiritual experiences?"
Not:
"Can you recite enough theology?"
But:
"Is your life moving toward Christ or away from Him?"
That is the direction-of-life test John repeatedly applies throughout 1 John.
The believer stumbles.
The believer repents.
The believer gets up.
The believer keeps following Christ.
That imperfect but genuine pattern of obedience is what John sees as evidence that someone truly knows God.